1. Mediaite
  2. Gossip Cop
  3. Geekosystem
  4. Styleite
  5. SportsGrid
  6. The Mary Sue
  7. The Maude
  8. The Braiser
ESPNMedia MonsterTabloid Fodder

Erin Andrews Was Torn Apart By A Los Angeles Daily News Columnist: Was He Fair?

The casual sports fan loves Erin Andrews. I’m a rising college senior, and when I went to College GameDay in Ann Arbor last year, the cheers for Andrews were almost as loud as those for Wolverine legend Desmond Howard. The audience was littered with giant signs of her face. She’s a veritable celebrity, and one with an overwhelming public approval rating.

But apparently, ESPN didn’t try that hard to keep her, and now she’s taking her talents to FOX. Now, about a week after the move was officially announced, Tom Hoffarth of the Los Angeles Daily News wrote a column absolutely tearing Andrews to shreds. He doesn’t seem to agree with the public opinion.

“The assumption is someone at Fox watched Andrews carom through week after week as solo host of the early expanded version on ESPN’s “College GameDay,” given an hour to read off her notes and awkwardly ad-lib on ESPNU before the real crew came to start the party. And they still hired her, apparently distracted enough into thinking she did a real swell job.”

This is a fair criticism. We’re not sure that we agree, but we understand. There are people out there that feel this way. It’s not unfounded.

But then Hoffarth starts attacking Andrews’ character to strengthen his argument. And it’s not pretty.

“A byproduct of the media world where it’s almost impossible anymore to be embarrassed by Twitter, YouTube, TMZ, Flickr or a racy text message – and with an appearance on an Oprah show always there to catch you when you need to explain what it’s like to be a victim in a celebrated Peeping Tom case — Andrew’s career arch has been bafflingly spectacular, titillating the masses who’ve apparently just stopped caring.”

Andrews was the victim of a Peeping Tom case. Yes, she went on Oprah explaining it. How is that relevant to her move to FOX? Calling her out for this is unnecessary and disrespectful. She was the victim of an incident involving a dude who planted a camera in the peephole of her hotel room door. There’s no need to act like this should be counted against her.

“The Erin Andrews Effect, as sports media phenomena, is attracting more female communications majors into taking as many shortcuts as possible to grab a coveted sideline reporting job or studio host instead of risking the time and challenge necessary to try play-by-play, game analyst, or even what’s still referred to journalism at a magazine, newspaper or website.”

Again, this is unfounded. How is this supposed “Erin Andrews Effect” something that attracts female communications majors to take shortcuts? Andrews was a telecommunications major at Florida, worked for Fox Sports Florida in 2000, the Sunshine Network for 2001-2002, and Turner South from 2002-2004. Her jobs? A freelance reporter, Tampa Bay Lightning reporter, and a studio host and reporter for Atlanta franchises. Hoffarth’s analysis here is just lazy and wrong.

He pegs Andrews as the reason behind an epidemic of females taking shortcuts, which he claims exists (with no evidence). But she clearly paid her dues, working for five years before being hired by ESPN. How she took “shortcuts,” let alone inspired an epidemic of females taking shortcuts, I can’t understand. Sure, she didn’t try play-by-play or newspaper journalism, but so what? They’re different jobs. If Andrews wants to be on TV, she’s allowed to be on TV. Just as Hoffarth is allowed to practice his type of journalism. Her choice of journalistic specialization isn’t up for attack.

“You’d think that by now, someone would have realized that her actions speak louder than her nasally vapid words.”

When attacking someone’s credibility, ad-hominem attacks are unwise. Whether her voice is “nasally” or not, calling her words vapid is scathing, again, without evidence. It wouldn’t be difficult to find a segment of her reporting a deep, emotional story on College GameDay.

“It speaks to the premise behind HBO’s new outstanding series, “The Newsroom.” Which is more important: Driving ratings or doing the news the right way?”

This may be the biggest problem with the column. If you don’t think she’s a great journalist, fine. That’s reasonable. But attacking her for “claim(ing) not to understand her own fame,” signing a shoe deal and just generally ripping her for having sex appeal is unfair. Having sex appeal is not doing news the wrong way. Andrews may not be the most talented journalist in sports, but she doesn’t do things the wrong way. Hoffarth can attack her talent all he wants, but undermining her integrity without any fair evidence is unscrupulous.

Hoffarth even acknowledges that his publication picks up stories about Andrews because she attracts viewers. So does that mean they’re doing things the wrong way? Are they unethical? Absolutely not.

Just like writers have the right to criticize a player’s performance, Hoffarth can say he thinks Andrews is awkward, untalented, or whatever he happens to think. That’s fine. But just as a balanced journalist wouldn’t say a struggling quarterback is doing things the “wrong way,” because he just isn’t good enough, Hoffarth should keep his criticisms to her on-air performance, rather than her ethics, unless he has better evidence.

[h/t Richard Deitsch; Inside SoCal]

  • Shaner

    Typo: But then Hoffarth starts attacking Hoffarth’s character to strengthen his argument. (Should be: “… attacking Andrews’ character …”

  • massapequaparking

    No, yeah, I get your point. Dancing With the Stars def a qualifier for sports journalism. Shocking Costas hasn’t gone that route.

  • http://www.sellmycarfast.net.au/ buy my car brisbane

    He doesn’t seem to agree with the public opinion.

  • Anonymous

    I don’t think the article was unfair at all. Rather, this article criticizing the original article is unfair…example…’She was the victim of an incident involving a dude who planted a camera in the peephole of her hotel room door. There’s no need to act like this should be counted against her.’

    Yo, Matt, Hoffarth wasn’t holding the peeper incident against her, he was holding her exploiting it against her.  Which she undoubtedly did. To. The. Hilt. 

  • Just Sayin

    “I’m a rising college senior…”  speaks volumes more than any thing else you’ve penned, here.

  • Sporto

    With all due respect, nobody really wants to hear a defense by somebody who knows very little about the world of journalism and was going through puberty a scant six years ago.

  • Sfdh

    MATT, shes still not gonna fuck you no matter how much you defend her……….

  • Marley

    Have her start at the bottom, lugging around camera gear and covering high school girls volleyball matches. She didn’t pay her dues. She’s just a pretty face. And what’s worse is that she inspired so many others to do the same.

  • Fidelcastro5150

    It’s obvious that most of you know nothing about Erin, her work ethic, her knowledge is unsurpassed as it relates to sports. Hmm What did her father do? Don’t know? Well shows you don’t know who he is, which alone would tell you more about Erin. She’s smart Knowledgable, funny and yes attractive. Most important of all these qualifications is the knowledge of sports. pay attention, then make a decision from knowledge, not from some article written by a jealous rival, who obviously wishes he had the knowledge she has. ( and maybe the looks as well.)

  • Anonymous

    ‘her knowledge is unsurpassed as it relates to sports.’

    Unsurpassed? Stop it. Just stop. You can’t write nonsense like that and expect anyone to keep reading. 

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/LWCMHM6QCQ2YRYTUWCC6SFAJ4M Dtweets

    YES BUT just HOW LONG is Erin Andrews going to allowed to keep playing THE POOR ME CARD??????? Move along people and make her do quality work for the money she is paid. She has yet to impress this person. Her voice is very difficult to listen to and SHE STUMBLES over every assignment.

    Erin is NOT ALL THAT! Get along day dreamers and get with the real talent.

    OBTW Erin Andrews is not the ONLY person at ESPN that their talents STINK! I tried to watch the Rangers on ESPN and the monitone voice and the lack of personality was very difficult to listen to so I turned it off!!!!!!!

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/LWCMHM6QCQ2YRYTUWCC6SFAJ4M Dtweets

    To top it off…. when she got the FOX job, she tweeted her old Dancing With The Stars partner Maks or as she calls him “RUSH” (gag) to say ‘Thanks Rush for helping me get the job at Fox’ WHAT! gag gag gag. And she has crow feet eyes and looks 10 years older than her age of 35 or whatever

  • Whatisthis

    What a shocking development that a network would hire someone that looks as good as Erin Andrews does to read from the teleprompter. This isn’t investigative journalism here so the ones who took the grinding path to get to the point where they can write an article in the dwindling  newspaper world and then  attack others for getting the offers they will never get that management knows attract viewers is petty and obvious envy. There are reasons why some write articles and some are put in front of a camera and it’s not a breaking news item. Phyllis George, Jane Pauly,Diane Sawyer,Jane Kennedy historically or any newscast daily is case in point.

  • Scottst

    I bet Hoffarth is just a libtard who’s upset that top talent has defected to FOX.

  • Anonymous

    >>  Andrews was the victim of a Peeping Tom case. [...] How is 
    >>  that relevant to her move to FOX? Calling her out for this is 
    >>  unnecessary and disrespectful.  

    It’s relevant because FOX is capitalizing on the tittilation.  All of Murdoch’s channels have long and sordid histories of claiming to be against sex in the media and then displaying near-naked women.  FOX is hiring her because of the pervert’s video.  She wouldn’t have been hired without it.  Murdoch and his corporation are slime.

    I guarantee that within the first six months of being on air, one of the “journalists” at FOX will make an insulting reference to the video right to her face, and she’ll be expected to sit there and take it.

  • Cardsfan24

    Erin Andrews, post keyhole:  “Please, give me privacy!”  2 weeks later: she was on Dancing With The Stars, showing off her assets.

© 2014 SportsGrid, LLC | About Us | Advertise | Newsletter | Jobs | Privacy | User Agreement | Disclaimer | Power Grid FAQ | Contact | Archives | RSS RSS
Dan Abrams, Founder | Power Grid by Sound Strategies | Hosting by Datagram | Sports Statistics Provided By Rotowire