Cal Raleigh's Stunning Decline: From MVP Contender to MLB's Worst

Segment Spotlight: Quick Hits From Pushing The Odds with Matt Perrault

Cal Raleigh's Stunning Decline After a Record-Breaking Season

Last year, Cal Raleigh, the catcher for the Seattle Mariners, monumentalized himself in Major League Baseball history with an exceptional performance that captivated fans and critics alike. Known colloquially as "the big dumper," Raleigh was not only a sensation on the field but also a magnet for endorsement deals, owing to his rare accomplishment of hitting 60 home runs—a feat almost unheard of for catchers. His outstanding performance positioned him fourth in all of baseball with an on-base plus slugging rate (OPS) of 948, near the pinnacle of single-season achievements for anyone at his position.

This season, however, tells a starkly different story. Raleigh's productivity has taken a nosedive, with his OPS plummeting to 564, ranking him last among 165 hitters with at least 350 plate appearances in the major leagues. From hitting 60 home runs last year to being on pace for just 17 this year, and with his RBI count drastically reduced from 125 to 43 as of mid-August, Raleigh's decline is both stark and troubling. With the Mariners currently out of the postseason chase with a 56-64 record, Raleigh's dramatic drop-off in performance could potentially be labeled as one of the most significant year-to-year collapses in baseball history.

Comparisons might be drawn to Hack Wilson's post-MVP performance about 95 years ago, when the Chicago Cubs legend faced a similar downfall after an exceptional season. However, even in his decline, Wilson managed to maintain an OPS near 800, a figure that Raleigh seems unlikely to reach this year. The situation raises questions about potential factors that could have contributed to Raleigh's current struggles, including the extensive innings and plate appearances last season that might have taken a toll on his physical condition.

With the current stringent steroid testing measures in place in Major League Baseball, which are described as the most aggressive in the sport's history, performance-enhancing drugs seem an unlikely culprit in Raleigh's slump. Instead, it may be a case of Raleigh having pushed his limits last year, potentially compromising his future performance for that one historic run. It is unclear if the Mariners are considering any negotiations or strategies regarding Raleigh's future, but his story serves as a somber reminder of how quickly the fortunes can turn in professional sports.