Why College Football Playoff Picks Need a Clear Metric
Dan Sileo
Host · Writer

Segment Spotlight: Quick Hits From Outspoken With Dan Sileo
College Football Playoff Needs a Formula, Not a Committee
The question comes down to which 12 teams deserve to be in the College Football Playoff. But why is a committee needed to select those teams? College football needs a formula rather than a group of people judging a beauty contest.
Other major sports do not rely on committees to determine which teams reach the postseason. In the National Football League, teams play their way into the tournament. In college football, teams must impress people to earn a place in the playoff.
When comparing teams with the same number of losses, what determines which one gets the opportunity to compete for a championship? Is it the strength of schedule, the quality of a loss, or the value of the program’s brand? The current metric is unclear.
There is also a concern that television interests favor recognizable brands over outlier teams that attract fewer viewers. That does not mean the teams selected for the playoff are undeserving, but it raises questions about whether every program is being evaluated by the same standard.
The reality is that not every team is equally positioned to compete for a national title. There may be only six teams with a genuine chance to win it, while the rest of the process becomes theater. A committee choosing the field only adds to that perception.
In the past, teams played in major bowl games such as the Orange Bowl, Rose Bowl, Fiesta Bowl, and Cotton Bowl. Sportswriters then selected the team they believed was the best in the country. At least teams played their way into that recognition, and those bowl games mattered.
Now, teams are judged by a committee every week based partly on how they look. Miami did not look particularly strong against Duke, but factors such as Malachi Tony may influence how that performance is viewed. That should not be the basis for choosing a national champion.
A team should qualify for the 12-team tournament through a defined metric. The system must move away from weekly subjective evaluations and establish a clear path into the playoff.
However, ESPN and Disney are unlikely to surrender their control over the College Football Playoff because it is a major moneymaker and a powerful way to promote their shows and properties. Their television relationships with the SEC and ACC also create questions about how teams associated with competing networks are presented.
Kurt Cignetti is right to question the metric. Although I am an SEC guy rather than a Big Ten guy, the system remains flawed because a committee controls the selections. His team lost to Ohio State by the tap of a toe, illustrating how narrow results can complicate subjective judgments.
Committees should not determine which teams get the opportunity to win a national championship. College football needs a consistent formula that clearly accounts for factors such as schedules and losses. The current process has to be fixed.
BETTING NEWS
FUTURES




