Top 20 Ohio State Buckeye Stars to Watch For In 2025 Season

20. DE Caden Curry

Caden Curry will decide whether to stay another year or leave for the NFL. However, I don’t think his draft positioning is where he wants it to be, so there is potential for a return to Columbus, where he would fill in at Jack Sawyer's spot on defense.

Stay ahead of the game and elevate your sports betting experience with SportsGrid.

2. S Caleb Downs

Caleb Downs came up to Columbus from Alabama, hoping to be a part of a National Championship run, and that’s precisely what happened. Downs played a significant role in Ohio State's defense, making plays all over the field. He will be relied upon again this season in an even bigger way.

3. WR Carnell Tate

Carnell Tate is projected to become Ohio State’s second receiver next season. He’s not talked about nearly enough, but this guy was a five-star recruit out of high school for a good reason, and he showed why last season.

4. QB Julian Sayin

Julian Sayin is officially QB1. With Will Howard moving on to the NFL, Sayin has big shoes to fill. With one of the most elite wide receiver corps in the nation and a solid offensive line, he has all the tools needed to thrive.

5. LB Sonny Styles

Sonny Styles transitioned to linebacker in 2024, finishing with 100 tackles and six sacks, showcasing his athleticism. He’s poised to lead the defense in a larger role. Expect him to be a dominant force and a potential All-Big Ten performer.

6. RB James Peoples

With Quinshon Judkins and TreVeyon Henderson now in the NFL, it’s time to unleash James Peoples. He didn't get meaningful reps last year, but his time is now.

7. WR Brandon Inniss

Brandon Inniss is another five-star recruit out of high school, who, unfortunately, barely saw the field last year due to the elite talent already on the depth chart. With Emeka Egbuka heading to the NFL, Inniss will slot in as the third receiver for the Buckeyes this season.

Matriculate down the field with SportsGrid’s FREE Top College Football Picks and College Football Player Prop Picks weekly! 

8. TE Max Klare

A transfer from Purdue, Max Klare caught 73 passes for 881 yards over two seasons, adding a dynamic receiving threat. He’ll benefit from attention on Ohio State’s receivers. Expect him to be a mismatch nightmare, potentially hitting 700 yards.

9. CB Davison Igbinosun

Davison Igbinosun's aggressive play led to nine pass breakups in 2024, though penalties were an issue. If he refines his technique, he could be a lockdown corner. Expect him to reduce his frequent flags and become a top NFL prospect.

10. LB Arvell Reese

Arvell Reese's athleticism is apparent, and he’s ready for a larger part in 2025. His pass-rushing ability adds versatility to the linebacker corps. Expect him to emerge as a breakout star with 50+ tackles.

11. DE Beau Atkinson

Transferring from North Carolina, Beau Atkinson brings 7.5 sacks from 2024, filling the void left by Jack Sawyer and JT Tuimoloau. His production will bolster the pass rush. Expect him to lead the team in sacks, potentially reaching double digits.

12. RB CJ Donaldson

 A West Virginia transfer, CJ Donaldson’s physical running style (743 yards in 2024) suits Ohio State’s system. He will have to battle with James Peoples for carries, but regardless, expect a breakout year.

13. C Carson Hinzman

Carson Hinzman regained the starting center role after Seth McLaughlin's injury in 2024, proving reliable. His leadership will anchor a rebuilt offensive line. Expect All-Big Ten caliber play and a strong NFL Draft case.

14. CB Jermaine Matthews

Jermaine Mathews flashed brilliance with his ball-hawking skills in 2024, ranking high in pass breakups. He’s poised to be a lockdown corner. Expect him to lead the team in interceptions and gain national attention.

15. DE Kenyatta Jackson

Kenyatta Jackson's explosive first step and 6-foot-5 frame make him a rising star on the defensive line. He’s set to start after a rotational role in 2024. Expect him to be a disruptive pass rusher with 6-8 sacks.

16. IOL Luke Montgomery

Luke Montgomery's versatility and aggression made an impact when he stepped in during 2024. He’s expected to start on the offensive line, bringing physicality. Expect him to solidify the interior and earn All-Big Ten consideration.

17. DT Kayden McDonald

Kayden McDonald saw some playing time throughout this season, but is now in a starting role since Ty Hamilton left for the NFL.  McDonald had 19 total tackles last season and will be relied upon in that defensive front.

18. LT Ethan Onianwa

A key transfer addition, Ethan Onianwa, addresses Ohio State’s need for offensive line stability. His talent could make him a one-year standout before going to the NFL. Expect him to protect Julian Sayin's blind side effectively.

19. DE C.J. Hicks

C.J. Hicks, now a defensive end for Ohio State in 2025, is expected to shine as a pass rusher with his elite athleticism. He’s poised to fill the void left by departing stars and could become a key defensive playmaker. 

20. DE Caden Curry

Caden Curry will decide whether to stay another year or leave for the NFL. However, I don’t think his draft positioning is where he wants it to be, so there is potential for a return to Columbus, where he would fill in at Jack Sawyer's spot on defense.

Stay ahead of the game and elevate your sports betting experience with SportsGrid.