NFL · 1 hour ago

ESPN Reveals Offseason Grades for All 32 NFL Teams: Draft, Trades & Free Agency

John Canady

Host · Writer

Arizona Cardinals: D
Biggest move: Releasing QB Kyler Murray
Move Seth Walder liked: Signing G Isaac Seumalo
Move Seth Walder disliked: Drafting RB Jeremiyah Love at No. 3

Releasing Kyler Murray marked the start of a new era in Arizona, though it also carried significant risk. Walder liked adding veteran guard Isaac Seumalo, but criticized using the No. 3 overall pick on running back Jeremiyah Love, believing the Cardinals passed on more valuable positions. It was an offseason filled with bold decisions that failed to earn much confidence.
Philadelphia Eagles: A
Biggest move: Trading WR A.J. Brown
Move Seth Walder liked: Signing CB Riq Woolen
Move Seth Walder disliked: Extending DT Jordan Davis

The Philadelphia Eagles made one of the offseason's boldest moves by dealing A.J. Brown, but Seth Walder still viewed their overall approach favorably. Adding Riq Woolen gives the secondary another high-upside playmaker, though Walder questioned the decision to extend Jordan Davis at his price point. Even after moving on from a star receiver, Philadelphia did enough to remain among the NFL's biggest offseason winners.
Los Angeles Chargers: A-
Biggest move: Hiring Mike McDaniel as offensive coordinator
Move Seth Walder liked: The McDaniel hire
Move Seth Walder disliked: Not spending more at guard

The Los Angeles Chargers took a major swing by bringing in Mike McDaniel to run the offense, a hire Walder believes could reshape the unit. Pairing McDaniel's creativity with Justin Herbert gives Los Angeles plenty of reason for optimism, even if the interior offensive line could have used more attention. It's the kind of move that could have a bigger impact than any free agent signing.
Miami Dolphins: A-
Biggest move: Signing QB Malik Willis to a three-year, $67.5 million contract
Move Seth Walder liked: Signing Willis
Move Seth Walder disliked: Roster left a little too bare

The Miami Dolphins made a surprising investment in Malik Willis, betting the quarterback's development is worth a three-year commitment. Walder liked the upside of the signing but felt Miami didn't do quite enough to round out the rest of the roster. Even so, the Dolphins earned solid marks for taking a calculated gamble at the game's most important position.
Chicago Bears: B+
Biggest move: Trading WR DJ Moore to the Bills
Move Seth Walder liked: The Moore trade
Move Seth Walder disliked: Not adding at edge

Trading DJ Moore wasn't an easy decision, but Walder liked the value Chicago received in return and viewed it as a smart long-term move. The biggest concern was failing to add more help off the edge, leaving a noticeable hole in the defense. If the pass rush holds up, the Bears could end up looking even smarter for reshaping the roster.
Cleveland Browns: B+
Biggest move: Trading Edge Myles Garrett
Move Seth Walder liked: Trading Garrett
Move Seth Walder disliked: Trading for OT Tytus Howard

Moving on from franchise cornerstone Myles Garrett signaled a new direction for the Browns, and Walder believed the timing made sense. He was less enthusiastic about acquiring Tytus Howard, questioning whether the price matched the upgrade. Cleveland embraced a reset, even if every move wasn't universally convincing.
Green Bay Packers: B+
Biggest move: Extending WR Christian Watson
Move Seth Walder liked: Extending Watson
Move Seth Walder disliked: Trading WR Dontayvion Wicks

Locking up Christian Watson gives the Packers stability at wide receiver and was one of Walder's favorite decisions from Green Bay's offseason. On the other hand, dealing Dontayvion Wicks took away valuable depth from the position group. The Packers kept their core intact while making a few calculated changes around it.
New York Giants: B+
Biggest move: Hiring John Harbaugh as coach
Move Seth Walder liked: Trading DT Dexter Lawrence II
Move Seth Walder disliked: Signing LB Tremaine Edmunds

Hiring John Harbaugh gives the Giants one of the league's most accomplished head coaches, but Walder was especially intrigued by the decision to trade Dexter Lawrence II. He was less convinced by the signing of Tremaine Edmunds, viewing it as an expensive addition at linebacker. New York wasn't afraid to make sweeping changes in hopes of accelerating its rebuild.
San Francisco 49ers: B+
Biggest move: Signing LT Trent Williams to a new contract
Move Seth Walder liked: Signing WR Mike Evans
Move Seth Walder disliked: Drafting WR De'Zhaun Stribling with the first pick in Round 2

The 49ers doubled down on competing now by extending Trent Williams and adding veteran receiver Mike Evans. Walder praised the Evans signing but questioned the use of such a premium draft pick on De'Zhaun Stribling. San Francisco continued to prioritize proven talent while taking a risk or two in the draft.
Detroit Lions: B
Biggest move: Drafting OT Blake Miller to help replace Taylor Decker
Move Seth Walder liked: Trading RB David Montgomery to the Texans
Move Seth Walder disliked: Extending LB Jack Campbell

The Lions began preparing for life after Taylor Decker by drafting Blake Miller, while also creating backfield flexibility by trading David Montgomery. Walder wasn't as sold on extending Jack Campbell, believing the resources could have been allocated elsewhere. Detroit stayed focused on building for the future without abandoning its current window.
Baltimore Ravens: B
Biggest move: Signing Edge Trey Hendrickson
Move Seth Walder liked: Signing DT Calais Campbell
Move Seth Walder disliked: Almost trading for Edge Maxx Crosby

Adding Trey Hendrickson gives the Ravens another dangerous pass rusher, but Walder also loved bringing back veteran Calais Campbell. The biggest criticism was nearly completing a blockbuster trade for Maxx Crosby, a move he felt would've been too costly. Baltimore remained aggressive without completely mortgaging its future.
Jacksonville Jaguars: B
Biggest move: Signing Edge Travon Walker to an extension
Move Seth Walder liked: Signing OL Cole Van Lanen to an extension
Move Seth Walder disliked: Drafting TE Nate Boerkircher in the second round

Extending Travon Walker keeps one of the franchise's foundational defenders in Jacksonville for the long haul. Walder also appreciated the team's decision to retain Cole Van Lanen, though he questioned spending a second-round pick on Nate Boerkircher. The Jaguars prioritized continuity while leaving room for debate over their draft strategy.
Carolina Panthers: B
Biggest move: Signing Edge Jaelan Phillips
Move Seth Walder liked: Not extending QB Bryce Young
Move Seth Walder disliked: Signing LB Devin Lloyd

The addition of Jaelan Phillips gives the Panthers another impact defender off the edge, while Walder also liked the patience shown with Bryce Young instead of rushing into an extension. His biggest concern came with signing Devin Lloyd, a move he viewed as less efficient value-wise. Carolina made steady, disciplined moves without chasing headlines.
New Orleans Saints: B
Biggest move: Drafting WR Jordyn Tyson
Move Seth Walder liked: Signing G David Edwards
Move Seth Walder disliked: Signing RB Travis Etienne Jr.

Drafting Jordyn Tyson gives the Saints another young weapon on offense, while signing David Edwards helped reinforce the offensive line. Walder wasn't nearly as high on the addition of Travis Etienne Jr., believing resources could have been spent elsewhere. It was a balanced offseason that mixed youth with veteran help.
Denver Broncos: B
Biggest move: Trading for WR Jaylen Waddle
Move Seth Walder liked: Re-signing LBs Alex Singleton and Justin Strnad
Move Seth Walder disliked: Re-signing RB J.K. Dobbins

Trading for Jaylen Waddle immediately raises Denver's passing attack ceiling and headlines the team's offseason. Walder also approved of bringing back Alex Singleton and Justin Strnad, but wasn't a fan of re-signing J.K. Dobbins. The Broncos addressed several key areas while taking a few risks along the way.
Tampa Bay Buccaneers: B
Biggest move: Drafting Edge Rueben Bain Jr.
Move Seth Walder liked: Signing Edge Al-Quadin Muhammad
Move Seth Walder disliked: Not retaining CB Jamel Dean

The Buccaneers added another intriguing pass-rushing prospect by drafting Rueben Bain Jr., while veteran Al-Quadin Muhammad earned praise as a savvy addition. Letting Jamel Dean walk, however, left a notable hole in the secondary. Tampa Bay strengthened one position group but weakened another.
Minnesota Vikings: B-
Biggest move: Signing QB Kyler Murray to a one-year, $1.3 million deal
Move Seth Walder liked: The Murray signing
Move Seth Walder disliked: Trading Edge Jonathan Greenard for two third-round picks

The bargain signing of Kyler Murray was exactly the kind of low-risk move Walder likes, giving the Vikings intriguing upside at quarterback. Trading Jonathan Greenard for two third-round picks, however, felt like selling too low on a productive pass rusher. Minnesota balanced smart value plays with one difficult-to-defend decision.
Seattle Seahawks: B-
Biggest move: Extending WR Jaxon Smith-Njigba
Move Seth Walder liked: Extending OT Charles Cross
Move Seth Walder disliked: Letting Edge Boye Mafe leave in free agency

The Seahawks secured two important building blocks by extending Jaxon Smith-Njigba and Charles Cross. Walder's biggest concern was allowing Boye Mafe to leave in free agency, which would create a void on the edge. Seattle invested in its offensive future but may have taken a step back defensively.
Tennessee Titans: B-
Biggest move: Hiring head coach Robert Saleh
Move Seth Walder liked: Signing DT John Franklin-Myers
Move Seth Walder disliked: Signing CB Alontae Taylor

Hiring Robert Saleh gives the Titans a respected leader to begin a new era, while adding John Franklin-Myers strengthened the defensive front. Walder wasn't nearly as enthusiastic about signing Alontae Taylor, viewing it as an underwhelming investment. Tennessee focused on improving its defense from the sidelines and on the field.
Atlanta Falcons: B-
Biggest move: Extending WR Drake London
Move Seth Walder liked: Signing QB Tua Tagovailoa
Move Seth Walder disliked: Extending TE Kyle Pitts Sr.

Extending Drake London ensures the Falcons keep one of their offensive cornerstones in place for years to come. Walder also liked taking a chance on Tua Tagovailoa, but questioned the decision to extend Kyle Pitts Sr. Atlanta made several bets on offensive continuity, even if not all of them were viewed equally.
Houston Texans: B-
Biggest move: Extending Edge Will Anderson Jr.
Move Seth Walder liked: Pivoting from Tytus Howard to Braden Smith at RT
Move Seth Walder disliked: Trading for RB David Montgomery

Keeping Will Anderson Jr. in Houston long term was an easy decision, and Walder also praised the pivot from Tytus Howard to Braden Smith at right tackle. However, trading for David Montgomery wasn't viewed as the best use of resources. The Texans solidified key positions while making one move Walder felt was unnecessary.
New England Patriots: B-
Biggest move: Trading for A.J. Brown
Move Seth Walder liked: Getting G Mike Onwenu to take a pay cut
Move Seth Walder disliked: Signing Edge Dre'Mont Jones

Landing A.J. Brown instantly gives the Patriots a true No. 1 receiver and changes the outlook of the offense. Walder also appreciated Mike Onwenu agreeing to a pay cut, though he wasn't sold on signing Dre'Mont Jones. New England made meaningful upgrades without earning universal praise.
Kansas City Chiefs: C+
Biggest move: Trading CB Trent McDuffie to the Rams
Move Seth Walder liked: The McDuffie trade
Move Seth Walder disliked: Trading up to draft CB Mansoor Delane

Trading Trent McDuffie was a surprising decision, but Walder liked the value the Chiefs received in return. His biggest issue came when Kansas City traded up for Mansoor Delane, a move he felt wasn't worth the extra draft capital. It was an offseason built on calculated risks that produced mixed reviews.
Los Angeles Rams: C+
Biggest move: Trading for Edge Myles Garrett
Move Seth Walder liked: Signing CB Jaylen Watson
Move Seth Walder disliked: Drafting QB Ty Simpson

The blockbuster acquisition of Myles Garrett gives the Rams another superstar defender to build around. Walder also liked signing Jaylen Watson, but wasn't convinced drafting Ty Simpson was the right move. Los Angeles added elite talent while leaving questions about its long-term quarterback plan.
Indianapolis Colts: C+
Biggest move: Signing QB Daniel Jones to an extension
Move Seth Walder liked: Signing Edge Arden Key
Move Seth Walder disliked: Transition-tagging Jones instead of franchise-tagging WR Alec Pierce

The Colts committed to Daniel Jones, but Walder's favorite move was signing veteran pass rusher Arden Key. His biggest criticism centered on using the transition tag on Jones instead of franchise-tagging Alec Pierce. Indianapolis addressed multiple needs, though not every contract decision landed cleanly.
Dallas Cowboys: C+
Biggest move: Keeping WR George Pickens on the franchise tag -- and only the franchise tag
Move Seth Walder liked: Keeping Pickens on the franchise tag
Move Seth Walder disliked: Trading DT Osa Odighizuwa

Keeping George Pickens on the franchise tag gives the Cowboys another season to evaluate his long-term future without a massive commitment. Walder also questioned moving on from Osa Odighizuwa, a departure that could hurt the defensive front. Dallas opted for flexibility, even if it came at a cost elsewhere.
Pittsburgh Steelers: C+
Biggest move: Re-signing QB Aaron Rodgers
Move Seth Walder liked: Signing CB Jamel Dean
Move Seth Walder disliked: Trading for WR Michael Pittman Jr.

Bringing back Aaron Rodgers ensures continuity under center for another season, while signing Jamel Dean strengthened the secondary. Walder wasn't nearly as enthusiastic about trading for Michael Pittman Jr., believing Pittsburgh paid a bit too much. The Steelers addressed obvious needs but didn't avoid every questionable decision.
Washington Commanders: C+
Biggest move: Signing Edge Odafe Oweh
Move Seth Walder liked: Signing S Nick Cross
Move Seth Walder disliked: Firing offensive coordinator Kliff Kingsbury

The Commanders bolstered their pass rush by signing Odafe Oweh, while adding Nick Cross gave the secondary another young piece. Walder's biggest criticism came with moving on from offensive coordinator Kliff Kingsbury, a change that could impact the offense's momentum. Washington improved defensively but introduced uncertainty on the coaching staff.
New York Jets: C
Biggest move: Trading for QB Geno Smith
Move Seth Walder liked: Trading for DT T'Vondre Sweat
Move(s) Seth Walder disliked: Acquiring aging veterans

Trading for Geno Smith gives the Jets a proven veteran at quarterback, though Walder's favorite move was acquiring T'Vondre Sweat to reinforce the defensive line. His biggest concern was the team's continued reliance on aging veterans throughout the roster. New York raised its floor but may not have done enough to improve its long-term outlook.
Cincinnati Bengals: C
Biggest move: Trading for DT Dexter Lawrence II
Move Seth Walder liked: Signing Edge Boye Mafe
Move Seth Walder disliked: Trading for Lawrence

Adding Dexter Lawrence II was one of the offseason's splashiest trades, but Walder wasn't convinced the price justified the move. He had far more praise for signing Boye Mafe, who fills a significant need off the edge. Cincinnati made aggressive moves, though not all of them delivered equal value.
Buffalo Bills: C
Biggest move: Firing coach Sean McDermott and replacing him with Joe Brady
Move Seth Walder liked: Re-signing C Connor McGovern to a four-year, $52 million deal
Move Seth Walder disliked: Trading for WR DJ Moore in a pick swap

The biggest change in Buffalo came on the sideline, with Joe Brady replacing Sean McDermott as head coach. Walder liked re-signing Connor McGovern but questioned trading for DJ Moore in a pick swap. The Bills made sweeping changes, though the overall roster-building strategy left room for debate.
Las Vegas Raiders: C
Biggest move: Drafting QB Fernando Mendoza No. 1 overall
Move Seth Walder liked: Trying to trade Edge Maxx Crosby
Move Seth Walder disliked: Signing Edge Kwity Paye

Drafting Fernando Mendoza first overall gives the Raiders their quarterback of the future, but Walder surprisingly liked the willingness to explore a trade involving Maxx Crosby. He was far less enthusiastic about signing Kwity Paye, viewing it as an overpay. Las Vegas embraced a long-term vision despite some questionable roster decisions.
Arizona Cardinals: D
Biggest move: Releasing QB Kyler Murray
Move Seth Walder liked: Signing G Isaac Seumalo
Move Seth Walder disliked: Drafting RB Jeremiyah Love at No. 3

Releasing Kyler Murray marked the start of a new era in Arizona, though it also carried significant risk. Walder liked adding veteran guard Isaac Seumalo, but criticized using the No. 3 overall pick on running back Jeremiyah Love, believing the Cardinals passed on more valuable positions. It was an offseason filled with bold decisions that failed to earn much confidence.
Philadelphia Eagles: A
Biggest move: Trading WR A.J. Brown
Move Seth Walder liked: Signing CB Riq Woolen
Move Seth Walder disliked: Extending DT Jordan Davis

The Philadelphia Eagles made one of the offseason's boldest moves by dealing A.J. Brown, but Seth Walder still viewed their overall approach favorably. Adding Riq Woolen gives the secondary another high-upside playmaker, though Walder questioned the decision to extend Jordan Davis at his price point. Even after moving on from a star receiver, Philadelphia did enough to remain among the NFL's biggest offseason winners.

ESPN Reveals Offseason Grades for All 32 NFL Teams: Draft, Trades & Free Agency

BETTING NEWS

FUTURES

EDITOR'S PICKS

For the Best of SportsGrid, Grab the App

BETTING NEWS

FUTURES