MLB · 5 months ago

Mike Trout’s Comeback Player of the Year Odds: Bet or Bail for Angels Fans?

Sportsgrid Staff

Host · Writer

Mike Trout’s Comeback Player of the Year Odds: Bet or Bail for Angels Fans?

The Los Angeles Angels have been waiting for the return of the real Mike Trout. Through the opening weeks of the 2025 MLB season, they just might have him. With +195 odds to win Comeback Player of the Year, Trout is once again making noise in the baseball world—and bettors are taking notice.

But is now the right time to bet on him? Or should fantasy managers and Angels faithful start preparing for the worst?

Swing for the Fences with SportsGrid’s free daily MLB Game Picks and MLB Prop Picks.

Mike Trout Is Powering Up: But Is It Fool’s Gold?

Mike Trout’s stat line is undeniably exciting on the surface:

6 home runs
14 RBIs
A modest .212 batting average

Trout’s power is back, but that low average feels eerily familiar. Last year, he began the season hot before being sidelined—again—by injury. That’s the crux of the Trout dilemma: his upside is MVP-caliber, but durability continues to haunt him.

This makes his Comeback Player of the Year betting line a bit of a double-edged sword. At nearly 2 to 1, there’s value—but also risk.

MLB MVP Long Shots: 5 Players Making Early Cases

Is +195 Worth It? Betting Value vs Injury Risk

At +195, Mike Trout is currently the betting favorite for AL Comeback Player of the Year. But here’s the key question: how much trust do you place in his health?

Reasons to Bet Trout:

Leading the AL in early-season home runs
Playing with renewed energy in a motivated Angels lineup
Betting markets still offer plus-money value

Reasons to Avoid or Cash Out:

Batting average (.212) suggests inconsistency
Injury history looms large
Other CPOTY contenders may offer better value at longer odds

In sportsbooks that offer early cash-out options, betting Trout now and monitoring his health could be a profitable hedge strategy.

Have all the intel you need? Free actionable info is one click away! Sign up for our daily newsletter.

Fantasy Baseball Insight: Time to Trade Mike Trout?

Fantasy managers face a different dilemma: hold or sell? If you roster Trout, his current hot streak gives you a rare window to capitalize on name value. He’s one of the most recognized players in baseball—but smart GMs know the clock may be ticking.

If you can trade him for:

A younger, more consistent bat
A top-25 overall fantasy player
A pitcher with higher innings confidence

…you should seriously consider it. It’s better to move him while his perceived value is high than ride the wave into another IL stint.

Cy Young Long Shots: 5 Pitchers Making Early Cases

Angels Outlook: Can Trout Anchor a Playoff Push?

From a team perspective, the Angels need Mike Trout at his best to stay competitive in a tough AL West. The return of his power stroke is energizing the fanbase and giving the team a chance to remain in postseason contention early.

Pairing Trout with young talent and solid rotation work gives L.A. a legitimate shot if he stays healthy. But if history repeats, that optimism may fade fast.