Mahomes vs. Hurts: Who Should You Draft in Fantasy Football?

When it comes to drafting quarterbacks in fantasy football, two names often dominate the conversation: Patrick Mahomes and Jalen Hurts. Both players offer elite-level production, but the question remains—who should you draft? This article will break down the key differences between the two and offer insights into why one might be a better choice for your fantasy football team.

Cleveland Browns & Cincinnati Bengals Playoff Odds in AFC North

Patrick Mahomes: The Consistent Passing Machine

Patrick Mahomes is a name that resonates with consistency and high performance. With over 5,000 passing yards in 2022 and 4,800 yards in 2021, Mahomes has proven time and time again that he can deliver elite numbers. What’s remarkable is that he accomplished these feats even without Tyreek Hill, showing that Mahomes doesn’t rely on one star receiver to produce.

Mahomes is a safer bet for fantasy football due to his consistent passing yards. If you’re looking to wager on total passing yards or touchdowns, Mahomes offers a higher floor and less risk.

Jalen Hurts: The Dual-Threat Dynamo

Jalen Hurts is no slouch either, particularly when it comes to adding points with his legs. In 2023, Hurts set an NFL record with 15 rushing touchdowns for a quarterback. While this adds significant value to his fantasy potential, it’s worth noting that replicating such a performance might be challenging. Concerns about Hurts’ rushing workload, particularly with changes in the Eagles’ offensive line and the possible reduction in goal-line carries, could impact his fantasy ceiling.

Hurts’ rushing ability offers high upside, but it also comes with more volatility. If you’re looking to bet on player performance, Hurts is a high-risk, high-reward option, especially in rushing categories.

Have all the intel you need? Free actionable info is one click away! Sign up for our daily newsletter.

The Impact of Draft Format

In single-quarterback leagues, the decision between Mahomes and Hurts might not seem as urgent, given that quarterbacks can often be found in later rounds. However, in Super Flex leagues, where you can start two quarterbacks, the stakes are much higher. Once the first quarterback comes off the board, typically Josh Allen, the domino effect begins. Mahomes is usually the next to go, and for a good reason—his track record is hard to ignore.

In Super Flex leagues, prioritizing a top-tier quarterback like Mahomes or Hurts could be the key to a successful fantasy season. Consider betting on total fantasy points, as Mahomes might offer more consistency, while Hurts could provide explosive games.

Assessing Bo Nix’s Fit and Future with the Denver Broncos

Conclusion: Mahomes or Hurts?

If you’re aiming for consistency and a high floor, Patrick Mahomes is your guy. His ability to put up massive passing numbers year after year makes him a reliable choice. On the other hand, if you’re willing to take a gamble on a player with a higher ceiling but also higher risk, Jalen Hurts could be your man.

Ultimately, the decision comes down to your draft strategy and risk tolerance. But one thing is clear—both Mahomes and Hurts have the potential to lead your fantasy team to glory. Just be ready to pull the trigger once that first quarterback is drafted.

Whether you’re placing bets on total passing yards, rushing touchdowns, or overall fantasy points, understanding the strengths and weaknesses of each quarterback can give you an edge. Mahomes offers stability, while Hurts presents the opportunity for big returns—if everything falls into place.

Stay ahead of the game and elevate your sports betting experience with SportsGrid.