7 Players Detroit Tigers Should Target to Return to 2025 MLB Playoffs

Strengthen the Starting Rotation

The Tigers showed promise in 2024 but faced challenges with their pitching depth. Tarik Skubal emerged as a dependable ace with a 2.37 ERA, but the rotation lacked consistency behind him. Injuries plagued key arms like Casey Mize and Reese Olson, while others underperformed. To compete in 2025, the Tigers must add another top-tier starter to solidify the rotation.

A reliable veteran like Nick Pivetta, who posted solid strikeout numbers in 2023, could fill this need without breaking the bank. Walker Buehler is another intriguing option if Detroit can help him regain his pre-injury form. Adding this depth will relieve pressure on prospects like Jackson Jobe and give the Tigers a chance to thrive in a competitive AL Central.

Add a Right-Handed Power Bat

The Tigers’ lineup is lefty-heavy, and they need a right-handed bat to balance it out. Anthony Santander, who belted 44 home runs in 2024, is an ideal target to provide power from the right side of the plate. As a switch-hitter, Santander would add versatility to a lineup that struggled to produce against left-handed pitching.

If Santander is too costly, a lower-risk option like Tyler O'Neill, who has shown power potential, could also fit. A right-handed bat will help the Tigers diversify their offense and add much-needed firepower for the 2025 playoff push.

Stay ahead of the game and elevate your sports betting experience with SportsGrid.

Bolster the Bullpen with a Proven Closer

Detroit’s bullpen was heroic down the stretch in 2024, but it lacks a true closer who can consistently shut down games. Jason Foley has filled in admirably, but his 20% strikeout rate isn’t ideal for high-leverage situations. The Tigers need to pursue a closer with more swing-and-miss stuff to give them a reliable ninth-inning option.

Free agency offers limited options, but taking a chance on a veteran reliever or making a trade could bring in the necessary firepower. Adding a high-leverage arm would not only give the bullpen a boost but also move Foley back to a more comfortable middle-relief role.

For all your MLB deep dives, check out our friends at Just Baseball.

Download the SportsGrid App

Stay Ahead of the Game and Elevate Your Sports Betting Experience with SportsGrid. Download the SportsGrid App from the Apple Store and Google Play Store.

Upgrade the Corner Infield Spots

Third base has been a weak spot for the Tigers, and Spencer Torkelson’s inconsistency at first base adds to the concern. Despite hitting 31 home runs, Torkelson’s .221 average and 95 wRC+ in 2024 leave room for improvement. The Tigers need to target a proven bat at one of these positions. Christian Walker, who hit 33 home runs in 2024, could be a cost-effective option to add power and stability at first base.

Alternatively, a trade for someone like Alec Bohm, who posted a solid .280 average with the Phillies, could fill the third base hole. The Tigers need a corner infielder who can produce offensively and defensively if they hope to make a serious postseason push.

Swing for the Fences with SportsGrid’s free daily MLB Game Picks and MLB Prop Picks.

Strengthen the Starting Rotation

The Tigers showed promise in 2024 but faced challenges with their pitching depth. Tarik Skubal emerged as a dependable ace with a 2.37 ERA, but the rotation lacked consistency behind him. Injuries plagued key arms like Casey Mize and Reese Olson, while others underperformed. To compete in 2025, the Tigers must add another top-tier starter to solidify the rotation.

A reliable veteran like Nick Pivetta, who posted solid strikeout numbers in 2023, could fill this need without breaking the bank. Walker Buehler is another intriguing option if Detroit can help him regain his pre-injury form. Adding this depth will relieve pressure on prospects like Jackson Jobe and give the Tigers a chance to thrive in a competitive AL Central.