MLB Fantasy: Ranking Baseball’s Top 2B for 2025 | Semien, Marte & Altuve
Sportsgrid Staff
Host · Writer
1. Ketel Marte: Breaking Through at Second Base
Ketel Marte is no longer a sleeper pick; he’s now a top-tier second baseman. His breakout in 2023, followed by a stellar 2024, proved that his offensive power isn’t a fluke. After years of solid yet inconsistent performances, Marte’s back-to-back strong seasons, including a World Series run, solidified him as a reliable option. With Corbin Carroll and the potent Diamondbacks lineup providing support, Marte is a dynamic asset in fantasy leagues. If you’re looking for a keystone that delivers across the board, Marte should be at the top of your draft list.
8. Jonathan India: A Comeback Story in Cincinnati
Jonathan India’s value dipped after a couple of injury-plagued seasons, but the Reds’ second baseman is primed for a bounce-back. With new manager Terry Francona leading a young team, India will have the opportunity to showcase his speed and small-ball skills. While his power numbers may not leap off the page, India’s disciplined approach at the plate makes him a sneaky pick for fantasy managers looking for value at second base.
Stay ahead of the game and elevate your sports betting experience with SportsGrid.
7. Luis García Jr.: Solid but Limited Upside
Luis García Jr. showed flashes of power in 2024, but his overall fantasy ceiling remains capped. With 18 home runs and average sprint speed, García lacks the dynamic tools that would elevate him to an elite tier. While his strong 2021 Triple-A performance remains a positive sign, his limited speed and modest power make him a mid-tier option at best. Fantasy managers should draft him for solid, if unspectacular, production at second base.
For all your MLB deep dives check out our friends at Just Baseball.
6. Brandon Lowe: The Underrated Power Bat
Brandon Lowe has always been a power threat, but his lack of playing time against left-handed pitchers limits his fantasy potential. In 2021, Lowe hit 39 home runs, showing the kind of raw power that few second basemen possess. If Lowe can improve his performance against southpaws or land in a more favorable situation, he could challenge the top players at the position. Keep an eye on his status as the Rays navigate their roster decisions.
5. Jose Altuve: Is the Regression Real?
Jose Altuve had a solid 2024 season on the surface, but deeper metrics raise concerns about his long-term outlook. His hard-hit rate and exit velocity both ranked near the bottom of the league, signaling possible regression as he enters his age-35 season. Despite these red flags, Altuve remains a valuable player thanks to his contact skills and experience. However, his days of being an elite fantasy second baseman may be behind him. Proceed with caution when considering him in early rounds.
Download the SportsGrid App
Stay Ahead of the Game and Elevate Your Sports Betting Experience with SportsGrid. Download the SportsGrid App from the Apple Store and Google Play Store.
4. Jordan Westburg: A Rising Star in Baltimore
Jordan Westburg’s 2024 was cut short by injury, but the young Orioles infielder showed flashes of brilliance before then. His Statcast metrics paint a promising picture, ranking in the 92nd percentile for expected batting average and slugging percentage. Westburg’s potential as a power-hitting second baseman is high, and as the Orioles' offense continues to develop, so will his opportunities. Drafting him comes with some risk, but his upside makes him an intriguing option in deeper leagues.
Swing for the Fences with SportsGrid’s free daily MLB Game Picks and MLB Prop Picks.
3. Marcus Semien: Don’t Count Him Out
After a somewhat disappointing 2024 season, Marcus Semien’s fantasy stock took a hit. However, a closer look at his Statcast data reveals consistency beneath the surface. His power, speed, and decision-making at the plate remain elite. Expect a bounce-back season as Semien continues to lead the Texas Rangers’ high-powered offense. If you're looking for stability and upside at second base, Semien’s pull-side power and reliable production make him a strong candidate for your roster.
2. Ozzie Albies: The Risk Worth Taking
Despite being labeled as injury-prone, Ozzie Albies is an explosive force when healthy. Yes, he missed significant time in two of the last three seasons, but his 2023 numbers—33 home runs, 96 runs, and 109 RBIs—are hard to overlook. As a key player in one of the best offenses in MLB, Albies has tremendous upside. Fantasy managers who look beyond the injury concerns will be rewarded with elite production. Don’t let the health factor scare you away—Albies is worth the gamble.
1. Ketel Marte: Breaking Through at Second Base
Ketel Marte is no longer a sleeper pick; he’s now a top-tier second baseman. His breakout in 2023, followed by a stellar 2024, proved that his offensive power isn’t a fluke. After years of solid yet inconsistent performances, Marte’s back-to-back strong seasons, including a World Series run, solidified him as a reliable option. With Corbin Carroll and the potent Diamondbacks lineup providing support, Marte is a dynamic asset in fantasy leagues. If you’re looking for a keystone that delivers across the board, Marte should be at the top of your draft list.
8. Jonathan India: A Comeback Story in Cincinnati
Jonathan India’s value dipped after a couple of injury-plagued seasons, but the Reds’ second baseman is primed for a bounce-back. With new manager Terry Francona leading a young team, India will have the opportunity to showcase his speed and small-ball skills. While his power numbers may not leap off the page, India’s disciplined approach at the plate makes him a sneaky pick for fantasy managers looking for value at second base.
Stay ahead of the game and elevate your sports betting experience with SportsGrid.
