2025 NBA Playoffs: Knicks vs Celtics Game 5 Most Bet Player Props

Game 5 between the Boston Celtics and New York Knicks is set to be a pivotal battle, and bettors are zeroing in on player props with sharp statistical backing. From volume scorers like Jalen Brunson to key Celtics role players stepping into larger roles, the board is active with high-volume action on both sides. Let’s break down the most popular player prop bets at BetMGM ahead of this crucial Eastern Conference showdown at TD Garden.

Stay ahead of the game and elevate your sports betting experience with SportsGrid.

Most Bet Celtics vs Knicks Player Props (Tickets)

• Payton Pritchard over 13.5 points (-120)
• Jaylen Brown under 26.5 points (-120)
• Jalen Brunson over 28.5 points (+100)
• Josh Hart over 11.5 points (-110)
• Derrick White over 18.5 points (-120)

BOS vs NY Odds & Predictions, Free Picks, Prop Bets Today & Injury Updates

🔹 Payton Pritchard Over 13.5 Points (-120)

With Jayson Tatum sidelined and Boston searching for offense, Payton Pritchard is a popular over bet. He’s averaging 11.4 PPG in the playoffs, up from his 9.8 PPG vs. New York during the regular season. While still slightly below this line, Tatum’s absence opens the door for more touches. Pritchard scored 14.3 PPG in the regular season overall, and bettors expect him to rise to the occasion at home with an increased offensive load.

Dunk on the sportsbooks tonight! Grab SportsGrid’s free NBA picks, NBA props, and NBA SGPs.

🔹 Jaylen Brown Under 26.5 Points (-120)

Despite becoming Boston’s lead scoring option with Tatum out, Jaylen Brown draws significant under interest. He averaged just 16.3 PPG in four regular-season games vs. New York, and although he’s scoring 21.9 PPG this postseason, this line assumes a bigger jump than he’s consistently shown. Brown has averaged 26.8 PPG in the past 13 games without Tatum, but the Knicks’ defense against wings has been solid enough to cast doubt on a ceiling performance.

🔹 Jalen Brunson Over 28.5 Points (+100)

The Knicks’ go-to weapon, Jalen Brunson, has been dominant all postseason, averaging 30.1 PPG. That builds off a strong 26.8 PPG average vs. Boston during the regular season and his consistent clutch play throughout the series. With the Celtics’ defense weakened and Brunson thriving in big moments, bettors are backing the over at even money as New York looks to close out the series.

🔹 Josh Hart Over 11.5 Points (-110)

Josh Hart continues to be a reliable secondary scorer for New York. Averaging 14.8 PPG vs. Boston during the regular season and 13.6 PPG overall, Hart’s consistent role and minutes make him a steady over target. While he’s down to 12.4 PPG in the playoffs, Boston’s rotation shifts and Hart’s ability to attack the paint and hit spot-up jumpers support a lean toward the over.

🔹 Derrick White Over 18.5 Points (-120)

Derrick White’s offensive emergence has been critical for Boston this postseason. He’s averaging 18.3 PPG in the playoffs and 18.5 PPG in four games vs. the Knicks, showing remarkable consistency. With Tatum out, his shot volume should increase, and his catch-and-shoot efficiency makes this over a strong play in a must-win scenario.

BETMGM PROMO CODE – FIRST BET OFFER UP TO $1,500 BACK IN BONUS BETS

*All BetMGM Data is based on tickets and straight bets