MLB · 6 months ago

MLB Fantasy Baseball Draft Strategy: Targeting Mid-Round Starting Pitchers

Sportsgrid Staff

Host · Writer

MLB Fantasy Baseball Draft Strategy: Targeting Mid-Round Starting Pitchers

Finding Value in Fantasy Baseball Starting Pitchers

Once you reach pick 40 in fantasy drafts, the offensive player pool starts to shift. While you’ll still find big names like Oneil Cruz, Kyle Schwarber, and Jose Altuve, these players come with question marks—aging veterans, high-strikeout hitters, or overvalued prospects. This is where shifting focus to starting pitchers can be a strong strategy.

Ranking the AL Central Starting Rotations for the 2025 MLB Season

High-Upside Mid-Round Starters

Cole Ragans: The Sleeper Strikeout Ace

Upside: Ragans has elite strikeout potential, projected for 225+ Ks in a favorable division.
Draft Value: Available 30 picks later than Paul Skenes, offering similar strikeout upside at a lower cost.
Workload Advantage: Unlike Skenes, who may have inning limitations, Ragans is set for a full season.

For fantasy managers looking for a strikeout-heavy arm without sacrificing an early pick, Cole Ragans is a top-tier option.

Have all the intel you need? Free actionable info is one click away! Sign up for our daily newsletter.

Blake Snell: A Cy Young Contender in L.A.

Dodgers Boost: Snell joins an elite team with a deep bullpen and powerful offense.
Win Potential: Despite a possible six-man rotation, Snell could push for 20 wins with consistent run support.
Strong Finish in 2023: After a slow start, he dominated in his final 12 starts.
Health Factor: Compared to injury-prone Dodgers arms (Glasnow, Yamamoto, Kershaw, May), Snell is a workhorse.

Even in a six-man rotation, Snell offers elite production with high strikeouts and strong ratios. If the Dodgers’ rotation faces injuries, Snell could be the team’s most reliable starter.

Swing for the Fences with SportsGrid’s free daily MLB Game Picks and MLB Prop Picks.

Dylan Cease: A Steady Rotation Anchor

Durability: Makes every start, providing volume fantasy managers can trust.
Strikeout Production: Has consistently hovered around 200 Ks per season.
Draft Position: Available in the same range as Ragans, making him an alternative for those who prefer a safer bet.

Ranking the NL West Starting Rotations for the 2025 MLB Season

Draft Strategy: Where to Target These Starters

Early Rounds: Prioritize elite hitters like Vlad Guerrero Jr., Fernando Tatis Jr., or Francisco Lindor.
Mid-Rounds (40-60 range): Shift to Cole Ragans, Blake Snell, or Dylan Cease.
Why? These pitchers provide strikeouts, volume, and win potential without sacrificing early offensive production.

Ranking the AL East Starting Rotations for the 2025 MLB Season

Conclusion: Build Your Rotation Smartly

Cole Ragans offers ace-like strikeouts at a discount.
Blake Snell has Cy Young potential in a Dodgers win-friendly environment.
Dylan Cease provides stability and innings.
Avoid overpaying for early-round pitchers when comparable talent exists later.