New York Mets Top 5 MLB Prospects Heading Into 2025
SportsGrid Contributor Just Baseball
Host · Writer
1. Brandon Sproat – RHP (Triple-A)
For all your MLB deep dives, check out our friends at Just Baseball.
Brandon Sproat is one of the Mets' most promising pitching prospects, featuring an electric fastball that can touch triple digits. After being drafted twice by New York, Sproat has refined his arsenal, relying on a high-riding four-seam fastball and a devastating power changeup. His breaking pitches—a sweeping slider and a sharp curveball—give him plenty of tools to miss bats. The biggest hurdle for Sproat is his command, as inconsistent control has led to too many non-competitive pitches. However, improvements in his delivery suggest he’s trending in the right direction. If he continues refining his command, Sproat has the potential to develop into a frontline starter. Otherwise, his overpowering stuff could make him an elite high-leverage reliever. The Mets will closely monitor his progress in Triple-A, with a potential MLB debut on the horizon in 2025.
5. Luisangel Acuña – SS (MLB)
Thanks to Just Baseball for the stats, analysis, and insights in this slideshow article.
Luisangel Acuña, acquired in the Max Scherzer trade, has already made an impact at the MLB level. Though he struggled in Triple-A, Acuña looked much more comfortable after his call-up, showcasing his defensive versatility and speed on the basepaths. His approach at the plate remains a work in progress, as he struggles with pitch recognition and making consistent hard contact. However, his elite athleticism, quick bat, and ability to steal bases make him an intriguing player for the New York Mets moving forward. If he can improve his plate discipline and lift the ball more effectively, Acuña could develop into an everyday middle infielder. For now, his defensive flexibility and speed give him value as a utility player with upside.
4. Nolan McLean – RHP (Double-A)
Swing for the Fences with SportsGrid’s free daily MLB Game Picks and MLB Prop Picks.
Originally drafted as a two-way player, Nolan McLean has transitioned fully to the mound, where his plus fastball and wipeout slider make him an intriguing pitching prospect. His fastball sits in the mid-90s and touches 97 mph, while his sweeping slider generates plenty of swing-and-miss. McLean also mixes in a sharp cutter and a developing curveball, giving him a well-rounded arsenal. His command has steadily improved, though consistency remains a work in progress. With his ability to get ground balls and generate whiffs, McLean projects as a solid No. 4 starter with mid-rotation upside. He could reach the Mets’ rotation as early as 2026 if he continues refining his control.
3. Carson Benge – OF (Low-A)
A former two-way player at Oklahoma State, Carson Benge has quickly made a name for himself as an exciting outfield prospect. With an advanced feel for hitting, Benge combines excellent bat-to-ball skills with an improving power stroke. His ability to work counts and drive the ball in the air has helped him develop into a legitimate offensive threat. Defensively, he has a plus arm and great instincts, making him a potential everyday center fielder. While he’s still adjusting to pro pitching, his high contact rates and growing power give him the upside of a regular big-league contributor. If he continues to progress, Benge could be a key piece of the Mets' outfield in the coming years.
2. Jett Williams – SS/OF (Triple-A)
Stay ahead of the game and elevate your sports betting experience with SportsGrid.
Despite his smaller frame, Jett Williams packs a punch at the plate. Williams, a disciplined hitter with elite plate discipline, has one of the best walk rates in the minor leagues. His ability to work deep counts and avoid chasing pitches makes him an on-base machine. Defensively, Williams is versatile, showing solid range and a strong arm at shortstop while also getting reps in center field. Though his speed has dipped slightly due to added muscle, he remains an aggressive base-stealer. Williams missed most of 2024 due to wrist surgery but remains on track for a 2025 MLB debut. He could become a dynamic top-of-the-order threat if he continues refining his approach and defense.
1. Brandon Sproat – RHP (Triple-A)
For all your MLB deep dives, check out our friends at Just Baseball.
Brandon Sproat is one of the Mets' most promising pitching prospects, featuring an electric fastball that can touch triple digits. After being drafted twice by New York, Sproat has refined his arsenal, relying on a high-riding four-seam fastball and a devastating power changeup. His breaking pitches—a sweeping slider and a sharp curveball—give him plenty of tools to miss bats. The biggest hurdle for Sproat is his command, as inconsistent control has led to too many non-competitive pitches. However, improvements in his delivery suggest he’s trending in the right direction. If he continues refining his command, Sproat has the potential to develop into a frontline starter. Otherwise, his overpowering stuff could make him an elite high-leverage reliever. The Mets will closely monitor his progress in Triple-A, with a potential MLB debut on the horizon in 2025.
5. Luisangel Acuña – SS (MLB)
Thanks to Just Baseball for the stats, analysis, and insights in this slideshow article.
Luisangel Acuña, acquired in the Max Scherzer trade, has already made an impact at the MLB level. Though he struggled in Triple-A, Acuña looked much more comfortable after his call-up, showcasing his defensive versatility and speed on the basepaths. His approach at the plate remains a work in progress, as he struggles with pitch recognition and making consistent hard contact. However, his elite athleticism, quick bat, and ability to steal bases make him an intriguing player for the New York Mets moving forward. If he can improve his plate discipline and lift the ball more effectively, Acuña could develop into an everyday middle infielder. For now, his defensive flexibility and speed give him value as a utility player with upside.
