MLB · 30 minutes ago

Ranking the Top 5 Destinations for MLB Free Agent Pete Alonso

Grant White

Host · Writer

5. Cincinnati Reds
Cincinnati Reds World Series Odds: +3500

For years, the Cincinnati Reds have cultivated some of the best young talent in the majors, but they continue to come up short of expectations. Alonso's arrival would act as a catalyst, propelling the Reds to the top of the NL Central.

Cincinnati made significant strides in 2025, but it still ranks among the lower-scoring teams in the bigs. More concerningly, their limited run production was a hindrance in the standings. Finishing last season with just 22 wins in one-run games, the Reds had the fewest wins in the division and were tied for the third-fewest in the Senior Circuit.

Thin at first base and designated hitter, Alonso would be a welcome addition to the Reds' batting order next season. If they can sell him on the pitch, the Reds would vault into immediate contention for the 2026 World Series.

Stay ahead of the game and elevate your sports betting experience with SportsGrid.
1. New York Mets
New York Mets World Series Odds: +1100

The odds-on favorite to re-sign their All-Star slugger, the New York Mets will want to avoid extending the song and dance they did last year.

Pete Alonso remains one of the most coveted names in free agency. While his defensive gaffes cost the Mets a few wins last season, his power at the plate remains virtually unmatched. A career .516 slugger, Alonso is coming off his sixth 30+ home run campaign in seven seasons. That type of run production is not easily replicated at Citi Field.

If you thought the Mets were bad last year, wait and see what happens if they don't re-up with Alonso ahead of 2026.

Have all the intel you need? Free, actionable information is just one click away! Sign up for our daily newsletter, SportsGrid Daily.
2. Boston Red Sox
Boston Red Sox World Series Odds: +1500

The Boston Red Sox have been knocking at the door in the AL East, but have consistently come up short relative to the division's biggest spenders. Reportedly interested in making a big splash this offseason, don't be surprised if Alonso dons the red, white, and navy blue next season.

The Red Sox have fallen behind the likes of the Yankees and Blue Jays, and offense has been a big reason why. Boston sat a distant ninth in OPS last year, behind the top-ranked Yankees and third-ranked Jays. Without meaningful production from their first base spot in years, Alonso would be a welcome addition to the Red Sox lineup.

Adding Alonso's pop in the hitter-friendly confines of Fenway Park would be an ungodly advantage. The Red Sox's World Series odds will soar if Alonso signs in Bean Town.
3. San Diego Padres
San Diego Padres World Series Odds: +2000

As is typically the case, the San Diego Padres have been on the losing side of the NL West tug of war. While they've tightened their spending restraints in recent seasons, now would be an optimal time to go out and spend some dough on Alonso.

Like the aforementioned Red Sox, San Diego's run production from first base has been limited. Jake Cronenworth boosted production during his time at the cold corner, but he's better suited to produce from second base. Bringing in the five-time All-Star first baseman solidifies the top end of the order and gives the Padres some much-needed pop at first.

As we saw throughout the regular season last year, the Dodgers' reign atop the division could be tested again in 2026. With more power in their lineup, the Padres could earn a much-needed first-round bye with Alonso in the lineup.
4. Tampa Bay Rays
Tampa Bay Rays World Series Odds: +5000

Rarely a team to go out and spend, the Tampa Bay Rays have unmatched enthusiasm when it comes to recruiting local athletes. With new owners ready to make their mark, this could be their chance to nab a power bat for their depleted lineup.

Granted, Tampa Bay's run production woes arise from their powerless outfield. Still, a bat of Alonso's caliber doesn't come around often. Moreover, run production of any variety is a crucial piece of the Rays' puzzle this offseason.

Versatility is a hallmark of the Rays' success. Landing Alonso and then shuffling their personnel or trading away an infielder for a competent outfielder could be in the cards.
5. Cincinnati Reds
Cincinnati Reds World Series Odds: +3500

For years, the Cincinnati Reds have cultivated some of the best young talent in the majors, but they continue to come up short of expectations. Alonso's arrival would act as a catalyst, propelling the Reds to the top of the NL Central.

Cincinnati made significant strides in 2025, but it still ranks among the lower-scoring teams in the bigs. More concerningly, their limited run production was a hindrance in the standings. Finishing last season with just 22 wins in one-run games, the Reds had the fewest wins in the division and were tied for the third-fewest in the Senior Circuit.

Thin at first base and designated hitter, Alonso would be a welcome addition to the Reds' batting order next season. If they can sell him on the pitch, the Reds would vault into immediate contention for the 2026 World Series.

Stay ahead of the game and elevate your sports betting experience with SportsGrid.
1. New York Mets
New York Mets World Series Odds: +1100

The odds-on favorite to re-sign their All-Star slugger, the New York Mets will want to avoid extending the song and dance they did last year.

Pete Alonso remains one of the most coveted names in free agency. While his defensive gaffes cost the Mets a few wins last season, his power at the plate remains virtually unmatched. A career .516 slugger, Alonso is coming off his sixth 30+ home run campaign in seven seasons. That type of run production is not easily replicated at Citi Field.

If you thought the Mets were bad last year, wait and see what happens if they don't re-up with Alonso ahead of 2026.

Have all the intel you need? Free, actionable information is just one click away! Sign up for our daily newsletter, SportsGrid Daily.

Ranking the Top 5 Destinations for MLB Free Agent Pete Alonso

Sports Betting

Sportsbook Promos

Social Casinos