Trevor Story Thrives as the Boston Red Sox Continue to Win Games

From Forgotten to Foundational: Trevor Story of the Boston Red Sox Redemption Tour Begins

After two injury-riddled seasons and a lengthy road back, Story is finally delivering for the Red Sox. Once considered a near-bust free-agent signing, Story has quietly turned into a sparkplug in July—hitting .259 with 2 home runs and 6 RBIs over the past week, and showing signs that his power-speed combo isn’t entirely gone.

This version of Story doesn’t need to be the 30-30 dynamo he was with the Colorado Rockies. What the Red Sox are getting is something nearly as valuable: a clutch, experienced, emotionally driven hitter who stabilizes the infield and provides occasional pop from the bottom of the lineup.

And perhaps most importantly, he’s staying on the field—a luxury the Red Sox haven’t enjoyed since he arrived in 2022.

Betting Angle: Story’s Props Are Undervalued (For Now)

As Boston keeps climbing the standings and Story reclaims everyday duties at shortstop, betting markets are just beginning to adjust.

Trevor Story Prop Trends to Watch:

Total Bases: Frequently posted at O/U 1.5 at plus money — great value when he’s seeing the ball well.
Hits + Runs + RBIs Combo Bets: Look for numbers around 1.5 or 2.5 in games against left-handers (Story has historically fared better against LHP).
Home Run Prop: Recently listed around +650 to +800 — a longshot, but he’s slugging again and has favorable matchups coming up.

If Story remains hot, these markets will tighten post-All-Star break. For now, he’s a low-cost value prop bet with a resurgence narrative behind him.

The Red Sox are Heating Up — and Story’s Part of the Core

The hottest name in Boston is undoubtedly Ceddanne Rafaela, and rightfully so. But the Red Sox have seen consistent contributions from up and down the lineup lately—including Story. After being on the fringe of losing playing time earlier this summer, he’s now locked into shortstop and outperforming expectations.

Boston is now 6 games over .500 and pushing into Wild Card positioning.
Their team OPS has surged in July, driven by depth contributions like Story’s.
Story’s presence allows the Sox to stabilize their infield defense while waiting for potential trade deadline reinforcements.

This was a team that many assumed would sell by late July. Now? They could buy, and Story’s resurgence is part of that equation.

Future Betting Angle: Red Sox Team Props Worth a Look

If you’re buying in on Story’s bounce back, you should also be looking at the Red Sox in the futures market.

Team Futures to Consider:

Red Sox to Make the Playoffs: Currently around +135 to +180, depending on the book.
Red Sox Over Season Win Total (Adjusted In-Season): Many books have moved it to 83.5 or 84.5 — but with a softer schedule coming out of the break, the over is still in play.

Boston doesn’t need Story to be a superstar. But if he’s a steady contributor and occasional game-changer at shortstop, they’re deeper than most of the AL Wild Card pack.

Final Take: Story Isn’t an MVP, But He Might Be Boston’s X-Factor

Story won’t be a fantasy league-winner anymore. He’s probably not going to earn MVP votes. But that’s not what Boston needs.

What the Red Sox do need is a veteran with postseason experience, capable of both turning a game with a swing and settling the team when things get tight. That’s the version of Trevor Story we’re starting to see again.

Betting Recap:

Target total base and combo props while they’re still underpriced.
Lean Red Sox postseason futures if the lineup continues to click.
Watch Story as a low-key DFS value play vs. LHP.

Sometimes comebacks aren’t flashy—they’re foundational. Trevor Story is quietly rebuilding his legacy in Boston, and for bettors, quiet value is often the best kind.

You can read all about what’s going on in Major League Baseball at SportsGrid.com.