NFL · 1 month ago

2025 Indianapolis Colts Betting Preview: High Risk, Unclear Reward

Sportsgrid Staff

Host · Writer

‌

The Indianapolis Colts enter the 2025 NFL season with two major names — Anthony Richardson and Jonathan Taylor — leading the charge. But are they enough to justify betting on the Colts this year?

This team presents one of the most volatile profiles for both NFL futures bettors and fantasy football managers, and it’s time to break down whether there’s any real upside or just too much uncertainty to trust.

Tackle the Odds with SportsGrid’s Expert NFL Game Picks and NFL Player Prop Picks.

Anthony Richardson: The Colts’ Biggest Gamble in 2025?

There’s no question that Anthony Richardson was drafted with high expectations, but after an injury-shortened rookie season and a lack of progression in year two, the quarterback situation in Indy is anything but settled.

Richardson’s health and development remain red flags.
Veteran Daniel Jones is now in the mix and could start Week 1, raising concerns over the franchise’s confidence in Richardson.
Even in fantasy football formats that reward rushing, this QB battle is too murky to reliably invest in.

Betting implication: Without a clear starting QB, avoid Colts team win total bets or early-season spreads until there’s clarity under center.

2025 Fantasy Football: Tight End Draft Strategy and Analysis

Jonathan Taylor: Injury Concerns vs. Fantasy ADP

Jonathan Taylor has the talent to be a top-tier fantasy running back, but the recent track record is troubling:

Multiple ankle injuries over the last two seasons
A solid but not elite 2024 campaign
High 2nd-round fantasy football ADP in 2025

Given his recent history, many are turning to backup RB DJ Giddens as a late-round stash. If Taylor misses time, Giddens could provide major value in both fantasy and player prop markets.

Fantasy insight: Investing in Taylor is a high-risk, high-reward play. Hedge with Giddens where possible.

Prop bet angle: Consider Taylor under rushing yards or Giddens over total touches as speculative futures.

Saquon Barkley of the Philadelphia Eagles Stellar 2024 Season and 2025 Outlook

Wide Receiver Depth: Talented but Crowded

The Colts’ pass-catching group is solid but lacks clarity for consistent production:

Michael Pittman Jr. remains the top option, but has been inconsistent with QB changes
Josh Downs and Alec Pierce offer flashes of upside but lack week-to-week reliability
Rookie Tyler Warren, a tight end out of Penn State, could command intermediate targets and red zone looks. He’s been compared to George Kittle in terms of skill set and physicality

DFS impact: Avoid stacking any Colts receivers early in the year. Monitor target shares and snap counts before considering them in lineups.

Fantasy sleeper: Tyler Warren has late-round appeal in tight end premium formats.

Tier 6-7 Wide Receivers Heading Towards 2025 Season

Shane Steichen’s Coaching: Is Year 3 a Make-or-Break?

Head coach Shane Steichen was seen as an offensive innovator, but the results haven’t matched the expectations:

After two seasons, there’s been little progression in team identity
The Colts offense lacks consistency, and their trajectory appears to be uncertain or even regressive

With an offense that could move forward, stall, or fall back, this makes the Colts one of the most difficult teams to forecast heading into the 2025 season.

Key takeaway: 2 out of 3 possible outcomes (stagnation or regression) spell trouble. That’s a risky bet to take.

March down the field with SportsGrid’s FREE Top NFL Game Picks and NFL Player Prop Picks weekly!

Final Verdict: Avoid the Colts in Early Bets and Drafts

Until there’s clarity at quarterback and signs that Jonathan Taylor is back to full strength, the Indianapolis Colts are a stay-away team for both fantasy and sports betting. There are too many questions and not enough upside to justify early investment.