Fantasy Football Insights: Tyler Warren of the Indianapolis Colts

Tyler Warren: Indianapolis Colts Tight End Continues to Anchor Fantasy Lineups

The Tight End Landscape in 2025 Fantasy Football

The tight end position has long been one of fantasy football’s toughest to navigate, but 2025 has offered a rare burst of stability — and it starts with Tyler Warren of the Indianapolis Colts. While he stumbled this past week, Warren has been a model of consistency at a position defined by volatility. He’s logged double-digit fantasy points in nearly every outing and has become arguably the best tight end in fantasy football.

Behind him, a small but intriguing cluster of contenders has emerged. Tucker Kraft of the Green Bay Packers has surged into relevance, Jake Ferguson remains a red-zone factor for the Dallas Cowboys, and Trey McBride continues to post top-tier volume for the Arizona Cardinals. Even with this competition, Warren’s blend of usage and dependability keeps him near the top of the leaderboard — and for fantasy managers, that makes him a cornerstone piece.

Buy or Sell: Tucker Kraft Finishes as Fantasy’s No. 1 Tight End

Verdict: Sell

When asked whether Kraft could finish as the best tight end in fantasy this season, the temptation is there. He’s been excellent, sure, but the Packers’ offense has a crowded target tree — Christian Watson, Jayden Reed (when healthy), Romeo Doubs, Dontayvion Wicks, and others all demand touches. That makes consistent elite production tough to sustain.

Meanwhile, Warren, McBride, and Ferguson all have clearer red-zone paths and steadier roles within their offenses. Ferguson’s goose egg last week frustrated plenty of managers, but McBride’s workload (and an extra game post-bye) keeps him in the conversation. Still, Warren remains the steady hand in a turbulent position group.

If you’re betting on the rest of the season leaderboard, take the field over Kraft. There’s too much target competition in Green Bay for him to hold off the likes of Warren and McBride.

Why Tyler Warren Still Holds the Edge

Even after a rare off week, Warren remains fantasy’s most bankable tight end. His chemistry with Daniel Jones has been a major factor in the Colts’ offensive rhythm. Warren’s ability to stretch the seam, win in traffic, and serve as a red-zone go-to gives him a reliable fantasy floor and a weekly touchdown ceiling.

From a betting perspective, Warren’s anytime touchdown prop has been one of the more profitable tight end bets of the season, cashing in most weeks prior to his latest dud. In season-long fantasy formats, Warren’s consistency keeps him in play as the No. 1 tight end rest-of-season — particularly with players like Brock Bowers of the Las Vegas Raiders sidelined or underperforming.

Buy or Sell: Bo Nix of the Denver Broncos as a Fantasy Starter This Week

Verdict: Buy (Avoid Starting)

Nix has delivered two impressive fantasy outings — shredding the Cowboys and putting together a clutch fourth quarter versus the New York Giants — but Week 9 brings a tough matchup. Facing Houston’s top-tier pass defense, Nix projects as a borderline QB1 at best. The Texans’ offense may sputter at times, but their defense is legit, ranking near the top in pressure rate and yards allowed per attempt.

Nix sits barely inside the top 10 fantasy quarterbacks this week, and with several strong alternatives on the board, it’s a buy to avoid starting him unless your options are thin.

Betting Outlook: Tight End Futures & Player Props

Looking ahead, the tight end race for fantasy supremacy — and betting props — is tightening. Sportsbooks continue to adjust season-long yardage and touchdown odds, with Warren’s market reflecting his top-tier consistency. While Kraft offers upside, his volatile usage and crowded depth chart make him a fade in most season-long prop markets.

If you’re seeking betting value, McBride and Warren remain the best plays for end-of-season statistical leads. Ferguson’s volatility keeps him in GPP-only DFS conversations, while Kraft’s rise is intriguing — but likely capped by the Packers’ target distribution.

Bottom Line

The tight end position is finally offering reliable fantasy production — and  Warren is leading the way. A single off week doesn’t change his status as a top-end fantasy and betting asset. Whether you’re looking at rest-of-season rankings or player props, Warren remains the smart play — steady, productive, and essential for any fantasy playoff push.

You can read all about what’s going on in the National Football League at SportsGrid.com.