4. Jonathan Taylor (+2500)
Between Williams and Gibbs is the only AFC running back in the top five: Jonathan Taylor. After an offseason of trade speculation, injury concerns, and coaching change in Indianapolis, Taylor began the 2023 season on the Physically Unable to Perform (PUP) list. The team and Taylor eventually agreed on a contract extension, and the running back from Wisconsin was activated in October. Despite playing only ten games, Taylor had 741 yards with seven touchdowns. His yards per carry number was only 4.4, the lowest mark of his four-year career, but he was phenomenal down the stretch and ran for 188 yards on 30 carries against Houston in the season finale. The Colts let Zack Moss walk in free agency, and Shane Steichen is a well-regarded offensive coach, so Taylor should have many opportunities to make his mark.
Jonathan Taylor Odds to Win Offensive Player Of The Year: +3500