2025 MLB All Star Game: Best Player Prop Bets

Following an exciting home run derby, MLB‘s All-Star festivities conclude tonight with the 95th edition of the Midsummer Classic.

Here is everything you need to know, along with our top player prop bets!

Game Information & Where to Watch

• Date: Tuesday, July 15
• Time: 8:00 p.m. ET
• Location: Truist Park in Atlanta, GA
• Spread: American League -1.5 (+160) | Total: 7
• Moneyline: National League (-116) | American League (-102)
• TV: Fox
• Live Stream: Fubo

NYY Aaron Judge to Hit a Home Run (+560)

Arguably the most anticipated matchup of the evening is New York Yankees superstar Aaron Judge against Pittsburgh Pirates phenom Paul Skenes. Judge continues to post video game-type numbers, slashing an MLB-best .355/.462/.733 while ranking second in home runs with 35. Skenes has been equally dominant, pitching to a 2.01 ERA across 20 starts. The pair faced off in last year’s All-Star Game, with Judge grounding out to third. That said, if anyone can crack Skenes, it’s Judge, and at +560, the payoff could be as big as the swing.

FANDUEL PROMO CODE – GET $300 IN BONUS BETS

CHC Pete Crow-Armstrong to Record a Hit (+140)

Making his All-Star Game debut, 23-year-old Pete Crow-Armstrong has been instrumental in the Chicago Cubs’ success this season. Across 95 games, Crow-Armstrong is tied for sixth in the majors in home runs (25) and ranks seventh in RBI (71), all while playing Gold Glove level defense in centerfield. At +140 odds, backing one of the game’s rising stars to record a base knock feels like solid value.

Swing for the Fences with SportsGrid’s free daily MLB Game Picks and MLB Prop Picks