Justin Herbert: Betting on the Los Angeles Chargers’ Fantasy Ceiling in 2025
Fantasy QB1 in the AFC West?
The claim that Herbert will finish as the top fantasy quarterback in the AFC West is bold. On the surface, that means projecting Herbert to outscore Patrick Mahomes of the Kansas City Chiefs, Bo Nix of the Denver Broncos, and Geno Smith of the Seattle Seahawks. While surpassing Smith and the rookie Nix isn’t a stretch, putting Herbert ahead of Mahomes requires a leap of faith. The Chargers’ offensive scheme under Jim Harbaugh leans run-heavy, and unless Herbert posts massive efficiency numbers, he may not have the sheer passing volume to keep pace with Kansas City’s star. From a betting standpoint, the field looks like the safer play in “AFC West Top Fantasy QB” props.
Volume Concerns & Offensive Identity
Herbert’s fantasy ceiling in 2025 hinges less on his talent—which is elite—and more on the Chargers’ philosophy. With Harbaugh installing a ground-and-pound system, Herbert may not see the 600+ attempts he logged early in his career. Instead, the offense looks like “McConkey or bust.” Ladd McConkey should be his WR1, but beyond that, the pass-catching corps lacks proven threats. Quentin Johnston remains inconsistent, and Will Dissly is a blocking tight end first. If McConkey misses time, Herbert’s weekly outlook would crater. Bettors banking on Herbert overs in season-long props should tread carefully.
Fantasy QB1 vs. QB2 Debate
The separation between fantasy QB1s and QB2s often comes down to rushing upside or weapons. Mahomes has Rashee Rice and Xavier Worthy, Bo Nix adds mobility, and even Smith has Brock Bowers. Herbert, meanwhile, may finish as a strong real-life quarterback but a middling fantasy option. His likely range is mid-QB2 territory, where he’s serviceable but not carrying fantasy rosters. From a betting perspective, Herbert unders on passing yards or touchdowns could provide value if sportsbooks set his totals near pre-Harbaugh levels.
Betting Takeaway
Herbert remains a better NFL quarterback than a fantasy quarterback. He’ll keep the Chargers competitive, but the fantasy ceiling isn’t elite. If books list him in the top 6-8 range of QB futures markets, fading Herbert might be the sharp move. Betting against him winning the AFC West fantasy QB crown—or targeting unders on his stat totals—fits the current Chargers blueprint.
You can read all about what’s going on in the National Football League at SportsGrid.com.
